Directed by Benoît Jacquot
Starring Charlotte Gainsbourg, Benoît Poelvoorde, Chiara Mastroianni, Catherine Deneuve and André Marcon
A twist of fate leaves a hapless accountant romantically torn between two sisters.
See more films
★★★★★ review by HollandFocus on Letterboxd
Benoît Jacquot's previous film "Les Adieux à la reine" landed seven César nominations, going on to win three of the actual awards. It seems unlikely that "3 cœurs" will meet with similar success, which is a great pity as it may well be the director's finest couple of hours. While there is nothing especially original on display here, it's an immaculately assembled piece that features pitch-perfect performances from its four main actors.
Jacquot charges his namesake, Belgian star Poelvoorde, with the responsibility of carrying this emotional heavy-hitter, and the actor repays this faith by delivering a sensitive turn that's shorn of all the comedy and boorishness we've come to associate with his onscreen persona. Poelvoorde plays Marc, a Paris-based tax officer who misses the last train home while working in a provincial town near Lyon. While having a drink in a bar, he encounters Gainsbourg's inscrutable Sophie; the two walk together, form a connection, and arrange a meeting at Paris' Jardin des Tuileries. Due to a chaotic situation at work, Marc is late for the rendezvous and Sophie has left, resolving to move to America with the partner she was just about to walk out on.
Later on, and on another working trip to the town where he met Sophie, Marc meets Mastroianni's Sylvie and a relationship develops; marriage and a child duly follow. What we know long before Marc, however, is that Sylvie and Sophie are sisters. Obviously, when Marc comes to realise this and the US-based Sophie discovers who her sister is marrying, serious complications ensue. It should be noted that one of the three hearts of the title -- Marc's -- appears to be in very poor condition, and he spends much of his time seemingly just a croque-monsieur away from a heart attack; not the ideal condition, then, for taking on such a fraught emotional situation.
While the storyline is all very involving, this is essentially a character-driven piece in which the three main performers (plus Catherine Deneuve, sublime in the small role of the girls' mother) are all at the top of their game. The focus for most will be Gainsbourg and Poelvoorde, but in many ways the film belongs to Mastroianni -- always an engaging presence, here she gives what might well be her best performance. Given that for much of the story Sylvie is kept in the dark, and as such isn't afforded the same emotional peaks and troughs as her husband and sister, Mastroianni has to reach for other, more subtle means of expression to move us as her character deals with the quotidian details of being a wife and mother.
Gainsbourg and Mastrioanni, the offspring of four huge stars, are oddly believable as sisters and even manage to convince when it comes to depicting the extremely close bond that exists between Sophie and Sylvie. While much of the setup is familiar -- although Jacquot does invert the current trend by having a man torn between two women -- top class filmmaking can make us overlook the obvious in much the same way as these characters do.
★★★★ review by Rudi on Letterboxd
Compared to Hollywood romance movies this one is typically French in the sense that is not comical and misses action and pace. What we see is a well acted and good told story without softness and sugariness.
★★★★½ review by Edward Price on Letterboxd
Charlotte Gainsbourg is a camera's best friend. She is so gifted. I like this directors style too. I'll be looking for more of his stuff.
There was no blood, nudity, or explosions, and yet I really liked this movie.
★★★½ review by harlequin68 on Letterboxd
“3 Hearts” starts with Marc(Benoit Poelvoorde), a tax accountant, missing the last train back to Paris. To console himself, he gets a drink and then asks Sylvie(Charlotte Gainsbourg) about local hotels. They bond so well that they agree to meet in Paris in a few days’ time. Except Marc cannot make it due to heart trouble. So, Sylvie leaves with her boyfriend Christophe(Patrick Mille) to go to Minneapolis. That leaves her sister Sophie(Chiara Mastroianni) in charge of the family antiques business and in bad need of tax help. That’s where Marc comes in, being back in town on business.
So, I’m sure all of that sounds cute and/or romantic to you, right? But not to director Benoit Jacquot who sees the emotional pain in such a delicate setup, illustrated best by a musical score that is straight out of a horror movie.(That’s not to mention the casting of Charlotte Gainsbourg who has starred in three Lars Von Trier movies.) For example, these are two 30ish sisters who both have no trouble with leaving long term relationships at the drop of a hat or a reasonably charming stranger, although in the case of Sylvie that would also involve giving up Minneapolis for Paris. Granted, not all of it works, especially a third act subplot that goes nowhere, but it’s still an intriguing movie nonetheless.
★★★½ review by Chris Hormann on Letterboxd
Sylvie, Sophie and Hector. Three hearts, not beating as one. Deneuve disapproves. Crise cardiaque. Fin.
- See all reviews